‘Not necessary for everyone’: Heart experts oppose CAC screening for general public

Coronary artery calcium (CAC) tests are a simple, noninvasive way to image and evaluate the calcium deposits in a patient’s coronary arteries. However, according to a new message from the American Heart Association (AHA), these tests are “not necessary for everyone.” 

“The AHA does not recommend broad based use of the CAC test for screening,” Manesh R. Patel, MD, volunteer president of the AHA and cardiology chief at Duke University School of Medicine, said in a statement. “The association recommends it as a decision aid for people at borderline or intermediate risk for atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease or heart and blood-vessel disease caused by the buildup of cholesterol-containing plaque in the arteries—but only when the decision about whether to use drug therapy to lower risk is uncertain. It is a tiebreaker test.”

Guidelines developed by the AHA and American College of Cardiology (ACC) do support the use of CAC scoring for many at-risk patients, especially when there is uncertainty about whether or not cholesterol-lowering therapies or additional medical imaging may be necessary. More specifically, calcium findings are recommended to help guide treatment decisions for men 40 years or older and women 45 years old or older with a borderline or intermediate risk of experiencing a heart attack or stroke in the next decade.

Subscribe to Cardiovascular Business News

CAC tests are associated with key benefits for patients, including the relatively quick scan time—approximately 10 or 15 minutes—and the low radiation dose. The lack of contrast dye is another plus for clinicians to consider when considering whether or not to pursue a CAC test. On the other hand, the AHA did emphasize that these scans are typically not covered by insurance and could cost a patient $100 to $400 in out-of-pocket costs.

The AHA statement also highlighted the fact that a CAC score of zero does not mean a patient is free of any risks. Soft coronary plaques that can cause heart attacks are not visible in the non-contrast CAC scans.

“A CAC score of zero doesn’t rule out noncalcified plaque,” the group wrote. “Other factors that impact cardiovascular disease risk, including diabetes, smoking, very high cholesterol and a strong family history of premature heart disease, still matter.”

What is a CAC scan?

CAC tests are quick, low-radiation, noninvasive heart scans that measure calcified plaques in a patient’s coronary arteries. The results are used by clinicians to determine future treatment strategies. No contrast dye or IV needles are required, and no special preparation is needed ahead of the test.

CAC scans are performed with the use of a CT scanner and an electrocardiogram monitor. Patients may be asked to hold their breath for short periods of time.

Coronary CT angiography (CCTA) scans, which are quickly gaining momentum as a go-to imaging scan for heart patients, can also provide CAC scores. CCTA results are generally seen as a more effective way to evaluate a patient’s plaques, though the radiation dose is slightly higher and contrast dye is required.

Click here for additional details from the AHA.

Michael Walter
Michael Walter, Managing Editor

Michael has more than 19 years of experience as a professional writer and editor. He has written at length about cardiology, radiology, artificial intelligence and other key healthcare topics.

Subscribe to Cardiovascular Business News

Subscribe to Cardiovascular Business News